In the increasingly fraught child care landscape in the United States, centers based at workplaces are popping up more frequently.
Parents praise the model, given its convenience, affordability, and peace of mind. They can stop by to breastfeed or eat lunch with their little ones. And it doesn’t add time to their morning commutes. Employers view their entry into the realm as both a competitive advantage and a workplace morale-booster.
Why We Wrote This
A story focused on
As access to child care evades many parents, employers are trying to fill the void. Is on-site child care a short-term fix or an integral solution? Part of the series “Fixing the Child Care Crisis,” from the Education Reporting Collaborative.
In September, the Pittsburgh International Airport added its own on-site child care. Airport officials say the idea stemmed from wanting to bring more women and people of color into the aviation workforce. Plus, the airport sits 17 miles outside downtown Pittsburgh, making child care logistics challenging for employees.
On the other side of the country, Frances Ortiz, who works in accounting at The Venetian Resort Las Vegas, can’t imagine a better option. She says her 3-year-old daughter has gained independence and language skills – with Mom not far away – at the property’s on-site center for children of employees.
“She runs in here,” Ms. Ortiz says. “She grabs my badge. She has to open the door for herself.”
They exist in places like an airport, a resort, and a distribution center, tucked away from the public eye but close enough for easy access. They often emit laughter – and the sound of tumbling blocks, bouncing balls, and meandering tricycles.
They’re child care centers based at workplaces. And in the increasingly fraught American child care landscape, they are popping up more frequently.
Skyrocketing child care costs and staffing shortages have complicated arrangements for working parents. Some have left their jobs after struggling to find quality care. Employers, in turn, view their entry into the child care realm as both a competitive advantage and a workplace morale-booster.
Why We Wrote This
A story focused on
As access to child care evades many parents, employers are trying to fill the void. Is on-site child care a short-term fix or an integral solution? Part of the series “Fixing the Child Care Crisis,” from the Education Reporting Collaborative.
“In the absence of government intervention and investment, a lot of businesses have been stepping up to make sure that their employees can access affordable child care,” says Samantha Melvin, an assistant research professor at the Erikson Institute, an independent graduate school for early childhood education.
Parents benefiting from child care at their work sites praise the model, given its convenience, affordability, and peace of mind. They can stop by to breastfeed or eat lunch with their little ones. And it doesn’t add time to their morning commutes.
Frances Ortiz, who works in accounting at The Venetian Resort Las Vegas, can’t imagine a better option. She says her 3-year-old daughter has gained independence and language skills – with Mom not far away – at the property’s on-site child care center for employees.
“She runs in here,” Ms. Ortiz says. “She grabs my badge. She has to open the door for herself.”
In September, the Pittsburgh International Airport added its own on-site child care. The center, which is run by a child care operator, serves children of Allegheny County Airport Authority employees as well as those of select airport workers, such as food and beverage workers, ground handlers, and wheelchair attendants.
Airport officials say the idea stemmed from wanting to bring more women and people of color into the aviation workforce. Plus, the airport sits 17 miles outside of downtown Pittsburgh, making child care logistics challenging for employees. So far, it’s operating at about half capacity, with more enrollments expected over the next few months.
“It’s certainly an important proof point to our team that we mean it when we say that we’re invested in them and in what they need,” says Christina Cassotis, CEO of the Allegheny County Airport Authority, which operates the Pittsburgh airport.
An added bonus for the children: windows with views of planes taking off and landing.
How employers figure child care costs
The average American family spends nearly a quarter (24%) of its household income on child care, according to a survey this year from Care.com. The cost can eclipse rent or mortgages, if parents can access care in the first place. Many find themselves on wait lists.
As employers contemplate entering the child care realm, Ms. Melvin encourages them to find out what their workers want. What hours do they most need care? Are they looking for center- or home-based care?
Phatsimo Wenzel/Courtesy of Patagonia
The Care.com survey suggested that 30% of parents would like to see their employers provide on-site day care, while others identified child care subsidies (28%), flexible spending accounts (22%), and backup care (21%) as desirable workplace benefits.
More public and private employers appear to be heeding the call, though how they assist runs the gamut. Some fully run their own centers. Others outsource the operations and management to providers.
The financial arrangements also differ. Many companies and organizations don’t disclose the exact discounts offered to employees, but they tend to be more affordable than or at least competitive with local rates.
Walmart, for instance, recently opened an on-site child care center at its massive Bentonville, Arkansas, campus. The Little Squiggles Children’s Enrichment Center charges a monthly rate of $1,117 to $1,258, based on the child’s age, which company officials tell the Monitor in an email is “at market rate or below regional levels for comparable care.”
Another method gaining steam: employers providing subsidies for families to use toward child care options within their own communities.
KinderCare, a large child care operator with locations nationally, partners with more than 600 businesses and organizations to provide employee-sponsored child care, up from 400 in 2019, says Dan Figurski, president of KinderCare for Employers and Champions. Those employers represent the technology, medical, banking, academic, and public service industries, among others.
The amount of financial assistance they’re extending to employees varies, he says, with some covering up to 90% of child care costs.
Mr. Figurski expects more companies to view child care as a benefit for their employees, not unlike health care.
“I do think the future is some blended model of government-subsidized and employer-subsidized child care moving forward so that every child has access,” he says.
Experts who study child care, however, caution against an overreliance on businesses filling the void. Philip Fisher, director of the Stanford Center on Early Childhood, says doing so could undercut efforts to recognize child care as a public good.
“There’s a lot of well-intentioned people who are thinking this is a really good idea, and for those who would benefit from it, it could be,” he says. “Again, there are lots of downsides even in the short term.”
One of those potential pitfalls, he says, is instability if a parent suddenly loses their job and then has to find new child care and a new job.
“What our team members want”
In Nevada, The Venetian Resort’s child care center, run by KinderCare, sits in a back-of-house hallway steps away from the famous Las Vegas Boulevard.
All employees can enroll their children, as long as space allows, at a cost that’s generally 35% to 40% lower than KinderCare’s normal rate, says Matt Krystofiak, the Venetian’s chief human resources officer. The company also offers subsidies for employees who want to enroll their children in an off-site KinderCare closer to their homes.
Jackie Valley/The Christian Science Monitor
“We’re doing this because this is what our team members want,” he says. “This is what our team members need.”
Businesses such as Patagonia, another longtime leader in the space, also view child care as a reflection of their company culture.
The clothing retailer’s foray into child care began organically in 1983 when some of the company’s original employees started having children. As Patagonia grew, so did its child care footprint. Nowadays, the clothing company operates three child care centers – two in Southern California and one in Reno, Nevada – serving roughly 200 children.
The company conducts research annually to determine the cost to employees in each location, which leaders describe as an “average market rate.” Subsidies are available based on household income, says Sheryl Shushan, Patagonia’s director of global family services. The child care teachers are employed by Patagonia, so they receive corporate benefits as well.
On a recent morning, a 16-month-old boy toddled up a small embankment to touch wind chimes hanging from trees. His teachers watched from a short distance away in the outdoor classroom at Patagonia’s distribution center in Reno.
“We believe that risk-taking builds character,” says Terry Randolph, program manager for the site. In this play-based environment, children spend hours outside, digging in sand, riding bikes, playing with water, or climbing natural and human-made objects.
Patagonia leaders say the benefits on their end are stronger employee retention, a can-do spirit in the workplace, and a greater sense of community.
“There’s an opportunity to see co-workers as parents instead of just employees,” she says. “It just creates connection and purpose beyond the project you’re working on.”
For Alyssa Oldham, a classroom manager in Reno, the job and child care benefit meant rethinking her family size. She and her husband originally envisioned being a one-child family, given child care costs.
Now she comes to work holding two tiny hands belonging to her 4-year-old son and 1-year-old daughter.
“Working here, I was like, ‘We could have another child,’” she says.
This article, part of the series “Fixing the Child Care Crisis,” was produced by the Education Reporting Collaborative, a coalition of eight newsrooms that includes AL.com, The Associated Press, The Christian Science Monitor, The Dallas Morning News, The Hechinger Report, Idaho Education News, The Post and Courier in Charleston, South Carolina, and The Seattle Times.
Join us Wednesday, May 22, at 2:30 CST for an event led by the Seattle Times and AL.com, focused on the child care crisis and how to fix it. Panelists include Republican Sen. Katie Britt of Alabama, Democratic Sen. Patty Murray of Washington, and Lisa Hamilton, CEO of the Annie E. Casey Foundation. Follow this Facebook event for details.
Previous articles in the series:
May 14: Why states are stepping in to help parents with child care costs
May 7: ‘I can be mom and teacher.’ Schools show appreciation by providing child care
April 30: These cities raised taxes – for child care. How it’s changing parents’ lives.
April 22: The US child care system is in crisis. It’s hardest on moms without degrees.